To Advertise On Our Website Click Here

Posts Tagged ‘Amory Lovins’


Tuesday, October 26th, 2010

October 26, 2010
Nuclear Townhall
From The Editors


Of all the follies of the Green activists movement, none will ever compare with the ethanol mandate.

First proposed by Amory Lovins in Soft Energy Paths (1976), the idea of substituting biofuels for imported oil was quickly legislated by the Carter Administration and has gained strength ever since buoyed by powerful agricultural interests happy to see corn prices escalate.

At first the environmental lobby was ecstatic. Ethanol was clean, green, homegrown and proof that “soft” technologies could replace the “hard” strategies of prospecting for oil and gas or building nuclear power plants. Most exhilarating, ethanol came with its own constituency – the great Midwestern farm lobby. No longer would green energy be the obsession of a handful of East and West Coast sandal-wearing nature lovers. Now real farmers would be on their side.

Then reality set in. Corn ethanol has never been shown to produce any energy gain. It uses at least as much energy as it consumes. Oil imports have never quivered in the face of ethanol competition. It also damages engines. Now the news comes that ethanol actually creates more ozone-producing nitrous oxides.

Thus it is not surprising that environmental groups like the Natural Resources Defense Council are now protesting when the EPA raises the allowable mixture of ethanol from 10 to 15 percent in gasoline as it did this month. It’s all too late. With the mighty farm lobby hooked on ethanol, the juggernaut shows no sign of slowing. We now incinerate almost one-third of our corn crop in our gas tanks. Who is going to tell farmers to swallow one-third of their corn?

Robert Bryce, author of the best-selling book Power Hungry, details all this and more in a lengthy submission on National Review’s “Planet Gore.”  It’s hard to know whether to laugh or cry.

Read more at National Review



Monday, October 18th, 2010

Years ago, the conservative Weekly Standard ran a cover story called “The Myth of Alternative Energy.”  On the cover was gadfly Amory Lovins desperately pedaling a bicycle in an attempt to keep windmills and solar collectors going to generate electricity.

How times have changed. This week, in a brilliant coup, Lovins has persuaded the editors of The Standard to publish “Nuclear Socialism,” an anti-nuclear diatribe that follows the usual pattern of carefully selected facts, exaggerations and double standards, adding up to an argument that nuclear power couldn’t possibly get anywhere without government intervention.

Lovins rehearses the cost overruns of the 1980s, the bankruptcy of the Washington Public Power Supply System (WHOOPS!) and teases out figures suggesting that nuclear power is declining worldwide. What he misses is that there are 60 reactors under construction around the world, that Asia has embraced the technology and has jumped out to the forefront in developing it, that France has the cheapest electricity and lowest carbon emissions in Europe because it is 80 percent nuclear and that everywhere in the world except Germany people are deciding their fears of nuclear have been exaggerated and nuclear energy represents the future. If much of this is being undertaken by government-owned corporations, that is only because in most of the countries of the world the government owns just about everything.

To see why Lovins’ analysis doesn’t work, you only need repeat Milton Friedman’s dictum, “When government gets big enough, the only thing that can overcome it is more government.”  General Electric, Westinghouse and Babcock & Wilcox built 100 reactors in this country in the 1970s and 1980s without a dime of construction subsidies or insurance because the government allowed them. Now the regulatory burden has become so overwhelming that nobody can do anything. Last August, the Nuclear Regulatory Commission stopped site clearance for six weeks at the Vogtle plant – the only reactor that has received a federal loan guarantee – because Shaw, the major subcontractor, had failed to fill out written forms in questioning prospective employees about drug and alcohol abuse. No reactor will ever be built on time and on budget under such bureaucratic micromanagement and no construction project in the world could proceed under such oversight. Yet the TVA just completed the five-year rehabilitation of its Brown’s Ferry reactor on time and on budget – mainly because, as a quasi-government agency it has some push-back against NRC interference.

In the end, Lovins writes: "Here’s a principled alternative: Reverse the energy subsidy arms-race. Don’t add subsidies; subtract them. Take markets seriously. Not just for nuclear and fossil fuels but for all so-called ‘clean’ technologies, head toward zero energy subsidies, free enterprise, risk-based credit pricing, competition on merit, cheaper energy services, greater energy security, and dwindling deficits."

So let’s take him one better.  Let’s also eliminate renewable portfolio standards, state renewable mandates and other government directives that distort the market far more than loan guarantees that costs the government nothing if the project is finished on time. Then we will stop building windmills, solar collectors and nuclear reactors and put up nothing but natural gas plants – the risky, regressive and potentially disastrous path of least resistance down which Lovins and all the other anti-nuclear advocates are pushing us.

Read more at the Weekly Standard



Thursday, July 8th, 2010

You know nuclear power’s moment has arrived when the head of a French company with a Gaullic accent spends a relaxed half-an-hour talking to Charley Rose on national TV. That’s what happened Tuesday night on most PBS stations. “Has nuclear power’s moment arrived?” Rose began and Lauvergeon took it from there. The CEO has a very engaging manner, doesn’t patronize but doesn’t dumb things down, either. Rose was obviously impressed. Of course those French executives who have only learned English as adults still have a tough accent to interpret.

It was only two years ago that Rose spent a half-hour interviewing Amory Lovins and marveling that the whole country wasn’t listening to the Boy Einstein’s ideas of how to resolve the Energy Crisis. Lauvergeon’s appearance is a gratifying measure of how far we’ve come.

Click here to watch the entire interview