OSTENDORFF IN THE YUCCA VORTEX: NRC VOTE ON THE VERGE

When newly confirmed NRC Commissioner George Apostolokis cited a conflict emanating from prior work for the Sandia National Laboratories and abruptly exited stage right in mid-July from the Commission’s looming vote over the Atomic Safety Licensing Board’s rejection of the Energy Department’s Yucca Mountain license application withdrawal, all eyes turned to the recused Commissioner’s freshman colleague William Ostendorff.

With the Commission now levelized at two Democrats and two Republicans — and conventional wisdom suggesting that incumbent Commissioner Kristine Svinicki will negate a likely vote by Chairman Gregory Jaczko to overturn the lower panel’s ruling — Ostendorff has emerged as the pivotal vote on the matter regardless of what fellow Commissioner William Magwood, a Democratic appointee, decides to do.

According to a mix of NRC observers a vote on the issue ranges from either "imminent" to "before Congress returns in September."

Ostendorff’s vote can either ensure a 2-2 Commission stalemate or 3-1 majority vote to sustain the ASLB decision — or result in overturning the board if both Ostendorff and Magwood side with Jaczko — a former staffer for Yucca opponent, Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid.

For Ostendorff, the stakes couldn’t be higher.  A decision by the Commission to overturn the ASLB and allow a DOE license withdrawal could be a fatal blow to the two-decades-old $10 billion national repository program. The Commission action will directly  impact both a legal challenge to the Obama Administration’s termination effort and Congressional initiatives to revive the program.

Ostendorff’s vote is also complicated by political realities. He represents a Republican-blessed appointment to serve out the term of former NRC Chairman Dale Klein, a Yucca Mountain proponent who has been openly critical of the Obama Administration’s handing of Yucca Mountain.  With the term expiring in less than a year — June 30, 2011 — Ostendorff’s chances for re-appointment would be clouded by a vote undermining the ASLB’s unanimous decision given outspoken  Republican support for an increasingly bipartisan Congressional campaign to continue the program.

"Based on his Yucca vote, Ostendorff will either be a hero or a heretic," said one Capitol Hill observer.

Ostendorff’s decision is made even more ticklish by his February 9, 2010, Senate Committee on Environment and Public Works confirmation hearing.  In response to a question — posed by the Committee’s chair for Senator Reid — on whether Ostendorff would "second guess the Department of Energy’s decision to withdraw the license application for Yucca Mountain from NRC’s review", the prospective Commissioner said: "No."

In an early August decision declining to disqualify himself from consideration of the pending Yucca Mountain issue, Ostendorff offered a few clues:

"At the time of Senator Boxer’s question, I had only limited knowledge and appreciation for the matters at issue as part of the licensing proceeding, as well as only limited familiarity with DOE’s latest efforts with regard to that application. I certainly had no knowledge of the legal issues pertaining to the withdrawal of the application.

"I understood Senator Boxer’s question to ask whether or not I would take a position on DOE’s decision to seek withdrawal of the application as a matter of policy.  My belief at the time was, and still is, that it was not my place to question the decision made by the Secretary of Energy to  pursue such a withdrawal. 

"It was not my belief, nor do I think that any reasonable person could conclude as such in light of all the facts and circumstances, that Senator Boxer was asking for my opinion as to whether the application could be withdrawn as a matter of law. It was simply not conceivable to me that the Senator would ask me to provide an on-the-spot opinion on a legally and technically complex subject with simply a ‘yes or no’ answer, or to opine on the matter without having been given sufficient opportunity to understand the extensive history or complicated technical or legal issues."

Colleagues who have been associated with Ostendorff — during his tenures as principal deputy administrator for the National Nuclear Security Administration and Counsel and Staff Director for the Strategic Forces Subcommittee of the House Armed Services Committee — say they would be surprised by an Ostendorff decision to reverse the ASLB finding.  Speaking of the buttoned-down former nuclear. submarine commander who has been known to sport an atomic tie, one former colleague said:  "He is a man of principle who understands the rule of law and respects subordinates. He will do the right thing."

Tags: , , , , , , , , , ,

  • OTB

    No argument with this assessment. It will either be 2-2, 3-1 or 1-3!

    Let’s hope Ostendorff does “do the right thing” and rectifies his less than inspiring Senate confirmation charade..

  • OTB

    No argument with this assessment. It will either be 2-2, 3-1 or 1-3!

    Let’s hope Ostendorff does “do the right thing” and rectifies his less than inspiring Senate confirmation charade..

  • OTB

    No argument with this assessment. It will either be 2-2, 3-1 or 1-3!

    Let’s hope Ostendorff does “do the right thing” and rectifies his less than inspiring Senate confirmation charade..

  • Region II

    NTH — “…Ostendorff’s chances for re-appointment would be clouded by a vote undermining the ASLB’s unanimous decision..”

    Say what — “Clouded”. You’re being polite. Leaving aside the apolitical legally-versed strength of the ASLB rationale for their rejection of the DOE’s non-technical. non-science-based license withdrawal request, Ostendorff is toast points if he proves to be a pawn to Barbara Boxer and Harry Reid, much less Greg Jaczko. Checkmate.

  • Region II

    NTH — “…Ostendorff’s chances for re-appointment would be clouded by a vote undermining the ASLB’s unanimous decision..”

    Say what — “Clouded”. You’re being polite. Leaving aside the apolitical legally-versed strength of the ASLB rationale for their rejection of the DOE’s non-technical. non-science-based license withdrawal request, Ostendorff is toast points if he proves to be a pawn to Barbara Boxer and Harry Reid, much less Greg Jaczko. Checkmate.

  • Region II

    NTH — “…Ostendorff’s chances for re-appointment would be clouded by a vote undermining the ASLB’s unanimous decision..”

    Say what — “Clouded”. You’re being polite. Leaving aside the apolitical legally-versed strength of the ASLB rationale for their rejection of the DOE’s non-technical. non-science-based license withdrawal request, Ostendorff is toast points if he proves to be a pawn to Barbara Boxer and Harry Reid, much less Greg Jaczko. Checkmate.

  • White Flinter

    Logic suggests that the Commissioner’s depth of experience as a Navy officer and this line in his non-disqualification rationale — “I certainly had no knowledge of the legal issues pertaining to the withdrawal of the application” — give cause for confidence in the outcome of the Yucca Mt decision.

  • White Flinter

    Logic suggests that the Commissioner’s depth of experience as a Navy officer and this line in his non-disqualification rationale — “I certainly had no knowledge of the legal issues pertaining to the withdrawal of the application” — give cause for confidence in the outcome of the Yucca Mt decision.

  • White Flinter

    Logic suggests that the Commissioner’s depth of experience as a Navy officer and this line in his non-disqualification rationale — “I certainly had no knowledge of the legal issues pertaining to the withdrawal of the application” — give cause for confidence in the outcome of the Yucca Mt decision.

  • Legal Eagle

    If the Commission decides this matter on the merits of the Nuclear Waste Policy Act — which was the basis for the lower board’s decisive rejection of the DOE’s withdrawal request — it is a slam dunk. The Federal court will ultimately rule on this either way — and the Commission faces double jeopardy if they choose the wrong course of action.

  • Legal Eagle

    If the Commission decides this matter on the merits of the Nuclear Waste Policy Act — which was the basis for the lower board’s decisive rejection of the DOE’s withdrawal request — it is a slam dunk. The Federal court will ultimately rule on this either way — and the Commission faces double jeopardy if they choose the wrong course of action.

  • Legal Eagle

    If the Commission decides this matter on the merits of the Nuclear Waste Policy Act — which was the basis for the lower board’s decisive rejection of the DOE’s withdrawal request — it is a slam dunk. The Federal court will ultimately rule on this either way — and the Commission faces double jeopardy if they choose the wrong course of action.

  • Roll the Dice

    I wouldn’t count out Commissioner Magwood to do the “right thing.”. Think of this as five-card stud. Apostolokis and Jaczko’s cards have been played. It only takes a pair to win.

  • Roll the Dice

    I wouldn’t count out Commissioner Magwood to do the “right thing.”. Think of this as five-card stud. Apostolokis and Jaczko’s cards have been played. It only takes a pair to win.

  • Roll the Dice

    I wouldn’t count out Commissioner Magwood to do the “right thing.”. Think of this as five-card stud. Apostolokis and Jaczko’s cards have been played. It only takes a pair to win.

  • William W

    Leaving aside the pros and cons of the issue, the Commission can only be enhanced by showing judicial independence from Capitol Hill and the Executive Branch. Given that they were backed in a corner during the confirmation debacle, this could be best achieved by reaffirming the Board’s verdict.

  • William W

    Leaving aside the pros and cons of the issue, the Commission can only be enhanced by showing judicial independence from Capitol Hill and the Executive Branch. Given that they were backed in a corner during the confirmation debacle, this could be best achieved by reaffirming the Board’s verdict.

  • William W

    Leaving aside the pros and cons of the issue, the Commission can only be enhanced by showing judicial independence from Capitol Hill and the Executive Branch. Given that they were backed in a corner during the confirmation debacle, this could be best achieved by reaffirming the Board’s verdict.

  • Lastly a superb article in relation to the subject, maintain the good work and therefore I wish to examine much more of your stuff in the near future.

  • ha, I will try out my thought, your post get me some good ideas, it’s truly awesome, thanks.

    – Joe

  • Once and for all a good blog post in relation to the topic, continue the good work and therefore I wish to learn a lot more of your stuff in the time to come.

  • Finally a superb article related to the subject, keep up the great work and also I wish to read much more within you in the longer term.

  • At last a superb post about the topic, continue the good work and I wish to read far more of your stuff in the future.

  • At last a good writing about the topic, maintain the good work and also I hope to read much more within you in the future.

  • Then finally a great blog post regarding the subject, maintain the good work and also I hope to examine much more within you in the long run.

  • Finally an outstanding writing in relation to the topic, continue the great work and thus I hope to learn much more of your stuff in the near future.

  • Finally a superb blog post in relation to the subject, maintain the great work and thus I wish to read far more of your stuff in the longer term.

  • Lastly a good blog post related to the subject, keep up the good work and also I wish to learn far more of your stuff in the long run.

  • Lastly a very good blog post about the topic, maintain the good work and thus I hope to learn more of your stuff in the time to come.

  • Lastly a very good write-up regarding the topic, keep up the great work and thus I hope to read even more within you in the time to come.

  • Then finally a very good write-up regarding the topic, keep up the good work and thus I wish to examine much more from you in the near future.

  • Howdy 🙂 Would it be acceptable if I go a bit off subject? I’m trying to check out the blog on my new ipad but it will not display the right way, do you possess any kind of tips? Shall I try to obtain an upgrade for my software or something? Thank you for the support!

  • You not going to believe this but I have lost all day searching for some articles about this. I wish I knew of this site earlier, it was a fantastic read and really helped me out. Have a good one

  • This website is often a walk-through for all the data you wanted about this and didn’t know who to ask. Seem here, and you’ll really find it.

  • Apple now has Rhapsody as an app, which is a great start, but it is currently hampered by the inability to store locally on your iPod, and has a dismal 64kbps bit rate. If this changes, then it will somewhat negate this advantage for the Zune, but the 10 songs per month will still be a big plus in Zune Pass’ favor.

  • good post, added you to my RSS reader.

  • Just like somebody else reported what a fantastic blog this is. Generally I dont take the time with a remark but for your effort you warrant 1. Well

  • Congratulations on having one of the most sophisticated blogs Ive come across in some time! Its just incredible how much you can take away from something simply because of how visually beautiful it is. Youve put together a great blog space –great graphics, videos, layout. This is definitely a must-see blog!

  • Wow! Thank you! I always wanted to write in my site something like that. Can I take part of your post to my blog?

  • I dont know what to say. This is definitely one of the better blogs Ive read. Youre so insightful, have so much real stuff to bring to the table. I hope that more people read this and get what I got from it: chills. Great job and great blog. I cant wait to read more, keep em comin!

  • I’m getting a browser error, is anyone else?

  • Hi, I can’t understand how to add your site in my rss reader. Can you help me please?

  • This is by far the best looking site I’ve seen. It was completely easy to navigate and it was easy to look for the information I needed. Fantastic layout and great content!

  • Generally I do not post on blogs, but I would like to say that this post really forced me to do so, Excellent post!

  • Hello there 🙂 Could it possibly be okay if I go a little bit off subject? Now i’m attempting to check out the web log on my brand-new apple ipad tablet although it will not display correctly, do you possess any tips? Shall I attempt to find an up grade for my software or some thing? With thanks for the support!

  • Hi 🙂 Might it be acceptable if I’m going a bit off topic? We are attempting to watch the blog on my new apple ipad but it will not show correctly, do you possess any kind of advice? Shall I attempt to obtain an upgrade for my software or something? Thank you for the help!

  • Hi there 🙂 Might it be okay if I’m going a little off subject? I’m wanting to view the blog on my brand new apple ipad however it will not show the right way, do you have any suggestions? Shall I try to locate an upgrade for my software or some thing? Thanks for the assistance!

  • I would like to thank you for your efforts you’ve made in writing this article. I’m hoping the exact same best work from you in the future as well. In fact your creative composing abilities have inspired me to start my own BlogEngine blog now.

  • I do not accept as true with everything on that post, but you do make some very good things. I’m very excited about this subject and I myself act alot of study as well. Anyway it was a well thoughtout and pleasant read so I figured I would depart you a note. Feel free to check out my web page sometime & let me know what u feel.

  • hey great post,this all are the main point which we have to take care and we implement this.

  • Could not be written any better. Reading this blog post reminds me of my old room mate! He consistently kept discussing about this. I will forward this article to him. Quite sure he will have a fantastic read. With thanks for sharing!

  • I shall now demonstrate how works.

  • Interesting read. There is currently quite a lot of information around this subject on the net and some are most defintely better than others. You have caught the detail here just right which makes for a refreshing change – thanks.

  • I dont really know what youre talking about here. This cant be the only way to think about this can it? It seems like you know a lot about the subject, so why not explore it more? Make it more accessible to everyone else who may not agree with you? Youd get a lot more people behind this if you just stopped making general statements.

  • The next time I read a site, I hope that it doesnt disappoint me as much as this one. I mean, I know it was my choice to read, but I actually thought youd have something interesting to say. All I hear is a bunch of whining about something that you could fix if you werent too busy looking for attention.

  • I was searching for free streaming movies iphone online and after browsing through a few awful web-sites I ran across this one. I am really content. Thanks again and take care!

  • I think consistency is amongst the most important things for making a name for oneself…whether it’s consistency within how often you blog, comment, connect with people, etc. It’s all pertaining to consistency.

  • Rather liked your post together with your writing style. I will be stopping by your blog regular.

  • Look at the blog in the New York Times and read up on the same subject.

  • Splendidly done is richer reconsider than comfortably said.

  • I wish you by no means stop! This is one of the best blogs Ive ever go through. Youve gained some mad skill listed right here, man. I just hope that you dont shed your type simply because youre surely one from the coolest bloggers on the market. Please retain it up simply because the internet requires another person like you spreading the word.

  • how old is your blog? this is the first time I found it.

  • People like you should be ranked even better in search engines as this is what readers like me want to read. Content is great. Thanks

  • Intriguing , I wonder what the statistics are on your first point there…

  • What did you do, just say whatever it is you wanted to make people mad?! You cant just say something like that and not give any backup for it! Youve got to at least give me a reason to think that you know what youre talking about, otherwise, you just sound like some kid with a grudge!

  • I am often trying to find take pleasure in. This article awareness. would like to

  • Just checking out your article on my brand new Pantech Phone , and I wanted to see if it would let me reply or if it was going to me go to a full pc to do that. Ill check back later to see if it worked.

  • This information really helped me, I am sharing with a few friends.

  • you should post more often…

  • Nice info.I like all of your post.I’ll hold visiting this blog very often.It’s good to see you verbalise from the guts and your readability on this important subject will be easily observed.

  • great blog but some pictures will make it better

  • Certainly agree with just what you said. Your explanation was certainly the simplest to comprehend. I tell you, I usually get annoyed any time folks discuss issues that these people obviously don’t know about. You were able to hit the nail on the head and spelled out the whole thing with out complication. Perhaps, folks could take a signal. Will likely be back to obtain more. Appreciate it

  • you are my intake , I possess few web logs and occasionally run out from to post : (.

  • now in my rss reader)))

    thanxx

  • You completed some fine points there. I did a search on the topic and found most folks will agree with your blog.

  • you should post more often…

  • some really good blog posts on this internet site , thankyou for contribution.

  • Hi there, I discovered your own website through Google while researching for first aid for a heart attack and your post seems to be very helpful for me.

  • Thank you for making the trustworthy try to provide an explanation for this. I think very strong about it and wish to learn more. If it’s OK, as you reach more intensive knowledge, could you mind adding extra posts similar to this one with more information? It might be extraordinarily useful and helpful for me and my colleagues.

  • Thanks for writing this post! It prompted me to start my own blog about a similar subject 🙂

  • Very nice article and straight to the point. I don’t know if this is really the best place to ask but do you folks have any thoughts on where to employ some professional writers? Thank you

  • My buddy and I were just discussing this topic, he is usually trying to show me incorrect. Your view on this is fantastic and exactly how I really believe. I just now sent him this page to demonstrate him your own point of view. After looking over your website I book marked and will be coming back to read your updates!